Cultivating a unique “relational infrastructure” which feels accessible, transparent, kind and stigma-free for community-led research in Scotland

 

Background

Earlier this year, members of Community Knowledge Matters were invited to complete our 2026 members survey. The results of past members' surveys have proven extremely useful in shaping the scope and activities of CKM and this year is no different. The thoughtful, honest feedback from the CKM community is so appreciated by the CKM team and we felt it important to share some of the insights back with you.

Who makes up CKM?

With around 330 members across the network, we received many thoughtful responses to our 2026 survey (double our response rate from 2024). We are made up of a wonderful mix of ‘hats’ or identities as well, including third sector organisations, academic and independent researchers, artists and creative professionals, health and care practitioners, and funders. Of the 30 survey participants, 70% of respondents were based in Rural or Island Scotland with 90% based in Scotland overall. Participants of all ‘hats’ explained that they value sharing their work with other network members, as well as learning more about the work and ideas of others. However, community members and individuals with lived experience account for the majority at 60% of survey participants. These insights confirm that, though all are welcome within CKM, we remain a distinctly Scottish network with a strong rural and island base. 

It is also worth noting that policy and decision makers were the least represented group of survey participants, making up less than 4% of participants. This provides an insight about where connections could be even further strengthened going forward.

 

What about CKM is valuable to members?

Survey participants explained that the atmosphere of CKM spaces feels accessible, transparent, kind, and stigma-free. 

“I appreciate the network and the opportunities it provides for learning and connection.”

- Survey Participant

This year’s results also emphasised the integral role of our Community of Practice and Conversation Station sessions and monthly newsletter. Participants noted they especially valued the former for the conversational and open peer support space they provide. Communities of Practice and in-person Gatherings showed the highest active participation rate, highlighting that members value opportunities to connect. 

Through CKM events and resources, members explained that they have been able to more actively embed co-production in their day-to-day practice and share community-led approaches with friends and colleagues. Members also shared that they feel personally empowered, hopeful, connected, and more confident in leading research or using specific methods after engaging with the network. For example, one participant shared that CKM has supported them in recognising the value of what they have to contribute, including their lived experience.

Building on this, members also explicitly requested more practical, hands-on training and toolkits to further help translate ideas into tangible action.

“[CKM is] creating the special relational positioning and space that allows these discussions to happen; and the discussions themselves often feel unscripted, as in, we're exploring new vistas together…”

-Survey participant

 

Opportunities for growth

We are especially keen to hear feedback on how we can support the network further. One of the main barriers to engagement discussed by some participants includes managing to carve out enough time in busy schedules, as well as the length of meetings and network connectivity issues. This is something we very much acknowledge is a growing challenge across sectors and especially for communities and will continue to offer flexibility - for example, we have designed Community of Practices to be “modular” so people can just join for the first hour minutes rather than the whole 90 minutes if needed, and we also record our Conversation Stations.

“Thank you for creating such a supportive and collaborative network. I would appreciate more practical training sessions, opportunities to connect with members between events, and regular updates on funding and partnership opportunities.”

Others discussed the community knowledge sector’s need for sustained support for relational work and long-term peer connections. One person shared that there is an "overflow of resources, toolkits, and one-off events,” emphasising that CKM should continue to focus on facilitating connectivity over exclusively quicker “easy” outputs. This could include more active peer learning between network members who may benefit from working together. Members emphasised that this support can contribute to greater systemic shifts towards the value of community knowledge.

 

What next?

In terms of what the priorities of the network should be moving forward, members pointed us in three clear directions. Over 76% of participants wanted CKM to continue to facilitate relational spaces such as the community of practices, around 63% emphasised continuing to influence policy and decision-makers for system change, and 60% asked for a focus on building community-led research infrastructure, such as supportive skill building and connecting members with one another. 

The overarching priorities from survey participants were that CKM continues creating spaces for connection and discussion, advocating for the value of community knowledge and striving to make research more meaningful and accessible. Participants noted that this advocacy can become all the more impactful as CKM aims to continue work with policy and decision makers including through the data platform sharing rural community co-priorities for mental health and our Collective Voice work with the Collaboration for Mental Wealth in Moray community research network funded by UK Research and Innovation. 

As we move into the next phase of CKM as a network, we will remain rooted in the hopes and work of our members, with community knowledge driving everything we do. Stay tuned for updates on what's next for the network in the year ahead.

“[The] CKM network is a valuable and inspiring initiative - please keep going!”

- Survey Participant

Thank you to our members, steering group, collaborators and funders including The Ideas Fund, British Science Association and Wellcome Trust, new and long-time. Your contributions and engagement with the network are invaluable. We look forward to continuing to foster the CKM community and platforming community-led approaches.